Photo Credit: The New York Times
A new movie adaptation of the classic novel, Black Beauty was released on November 27th on the Disney+ streaming service.
The classic children’s novel was written in 1877 by Anna Sewell that tells the life of a horse from its own perspective. The adaptation was directed by Ashley Avis, who is a former competitive equestrian. The film is based in the United States during the modern-day. There are two female protagonists; the mustang horse Black Beauty who is voiced by Kate Winslet, and the newly orphaned Jo played by Mackenzie Foy. Both of the characters end up living at Birtwick Stables in New York with Jo’s uncle John played by Iain Glen.
However, the changed time period does not fit too well with the novel because its original historical background is entwined with the story’s narrative. It’s supposed to carry a deeper meaning and aim for justice for mistreated animals. Sewell’s novel focused on the misfortunes that fell upon them and how the treatment was excused or even encouraged.
Some names have changed, but the characters are overall the same. For example, the personalities minimally altered for the two horses, Ginger and Merrylegs. Also, John was accurately portrayed as a caring horse trainer. Although, a dimmer side of him from the book was not conveyed.
Black Beauty goes from a stallion in the novel to a mare in the film. The same change occurs for John’s assistant. Originally, a boy named Joe in the novel, to a niece named Jo. This substitute does not seem to change much. However, given the powerful message, it’s supposed to express, the focus should have been more on Beauty rather than both Jo and Beauty.
Since the attention was on both protagonists, more character development for Jo would have made the film less flat. She vaguely faced her family tragedy, instead focused on teen romance and reuniting with Beauty.
The film may be a refreshing take on the novel, but it only hints at the message its words convey. The theme of Sewell’s Black Beauty is clearly about animal-rights and for change in society. However, the film seems to be more focused on Jo and Beauty to find each other rather than the powerful theme of animal abuse.
The novel portrayed the death of Black Beauty’s friend, Ginger, in a more serious way than compared to the Disney film. Regardless, both adaptations express an emotional moment occurring in Black Beauty’s life.
Overall, the film does have beautiful cinematography and a decent storyline. Although, even with some changes made, the film, unfortunately, feels dormant at times.
